Reserve Now! Pricing and availability may change.

Public Storage - Middletown - 626 Highway 35

626 Highway 35, Middletown, NJ 07748
Rating Badge
5.0
(40)
Rating Badge
4.8
(329)
Online Move In Icon
Online Move-In AvailableRent online, skip the counter, and go straight to your space

Available Storage Units (16)

5x5

$2.12 / sqft
mini storage unit
Features
Roll Up DoorClimate ControlledInterior
$53.00
$70.00Only 2 Left!
Reserve Now, Pay LaterYou will not be charged until move-in

5x5

$2.16 / sqft
mini storage unit
Features
Swing DoorClimate ControlledInterior
$54.00
$72.00Only 1 Left!
Reserve Now, Pay LaterYou will not be charged until move-in

5x5

$2.32 / sqft
mini storage unit
Features
Roll Up DoorClimate Controlled1st FloorInterior

$1 first month rent

$58.00
$77.00Only 3 Left!
Reserve Now, Pay LaterYou will not be charged until move-in

5x10

$1.98 / sqft
small storage unit
Features
Roll Up DoorClimate ControlledInterior
$99.00
$131.00
Reserve Now, Pay LaterYou will not be charged until move-in

5x10

$2.16 / sqft
small storage unit
Features
Roll Up DoorClimate Controlled1st FloorInterior
$108.00
$143.00Only 1 Left!
Reserve Now, Pay LaterYou will not be charged until move-in

8x10

$1.85 / sqft
medium storage unit
Features
Roll Up DoorClimate Controlled1st FloorInterior

50% off 1st Month

$148.00
$197.00Only 1 Left!
Reserve Now, Pay LaterYou will not be charged until move-in

10x10

$1.37 / sqft
medium storage unit
Features
Roll Up DoorClimate ControlledInterior

50% off 1st Month

$137.00
$183.00
Reserve Now, Pay LaterYou will not be charged until move-in

10x10

$1.72 / sqft
medium storage unit
Features
Roll Up DoorClimate Controlled1st FloorInterior

$1 first month rent

$172.00
$229.00
Reserve Now, Pay LaterYou will not be charged until move-in

10x15

$1.13 / sqft
medium storage unit
Features
Roll Up DoorClimate Controlled1st FloorInterior
$170.00
$218.00Only 1 Left!
Reserve Now, Pay LaterYou will not be charged until move-in

10x15

$1.40 / sqft
medium storage unit
Features
Roll Up DoorClimate Controlled1st FloorInterior

50% off 1st Month

$210.00
$269.00
Reserve Now, Pay LaterYou will not be charged until move-in

10x20

$1.37 / sqft
medium storage unit
Features
Roll Up DoorDrive Up AccessOutdoor Access1st FloorVehicle

50% off 1st Month

$274.00
$362.00Only 1 Left!
Reserve Now, Pay LaterYou will not be charged until move-in

10x20

$1.59 / sqft
medium storage unit
Features
Roll Up DoorClimate Controlled1st FloorInterior
$319.00
$421.00Only 1 Left!
Reserve Now, Pay LaterYou will not be charged until move-in

10x30

$1.11 / sqft
large storage unit
Features
Roll Up DoorDrive Up AccessOutdoor Access1st FloorVehicle

2nd Month Free

$332.00
$406.00
Reserve Now, Pay LaterYou will not be charged until move-in

10x20

$1.37 / sqft
medium storage unit
Features
Roll Up DoorDrive Up AccessOutdoor Access1st FloorVehicle

50% off 1st Month

$274.00
$362.00Only 1 Left!
Reserve Now, Pay LaterYou will not be charged until move-in

9x24

$0.72 / sqft
Vehicle unit
Features
Drive Up AccessVehicleOutdoor-uncovered
$155.00
$205.00Only 1 Left!
Reserve Now, Pay LaterYou will not be charged until move-in

10x30

$1.11 / sqft
large storage unit
Features
Roll Up DoorDrive Up AccessOutdoor Access1st FloorVehicle

2nd Month Free

$332.00
$406.00
Reserve Now, Pay LaterYou will not be charged until move-in

Complete Amenities & Features

ACCESS

  • Electronic gate accessElectronic gate access
  • ElevatorElevator

SECURITY

  • Fenced + LightedFenced + Lighted

OFFICE HOURS
Sunday9:30 AM – 5:00 PM
Monday9:30 AM – 6:00 PM
Tuesday9:30 AM – 6:00 PM
Wednesday9:30 AM – 6:00 PM
Thursday9:30 AM – 6:00 PM
Friday9:30 AM – 6:00 PM
Saturday9:30 AM – 5:00 PM
ACCESS HOURS
Sunday6:00 AM – 9:00 PM
Monday6:00 AM – 9:00 PM
Tuesday6:00 AM – 9:00 PM
Wednesday6:00 AM – 9:00 PM
Thursday6:00 AM – 9:00 PM
Friday6:00 AM – 9:00 PM
Saturday6:00 AM – 9:00 PM

VEHICLE STORAGE REQUIREMENTS

  • Requires titleRequires title
  • Requires registrationRequires registration
  • Requires insuranceRequires insurance
  • Must be drivableMust be drivable

PROPERTY COVERAGE

  • Insurance requiredInsurance required
  • Insurance available for purchaseInsurance available for purchase
  • Homeowners or renters insurance acceptedHomeowners or renters insurance accepted

PAYMENTS

  • CashCash
  • Credit cards accepted: Visa, AMEX, Mastercard, DiscoverCredit cards accepted: Visa, AMEX, Mastercard, Discover
  • CheckCheck

BILLING

  • Email invoicing availableEmail invoicing available
  • Automatic payments availableAutomatic payments available
  • Rent due on same day each month per lease startRent due on same day each month per lease start

MISCELLANEOUS

  • Moving supplies for saleMoving supplies for sale

Customer Reviews

5.0(40)
Verified (40)Google (329)

Clean and Easily Accessible

by Shirley

October 20, 2025

5.0

The storage unit is clean dry and easily accessible. Unfortunately there is not always someone in the office during business hours. When one calls customer service there is no live operator. That’s very frustrating especially if you have an emergency while on the property.

Very professional and helpful

by LINDA

September 12, 2019

5.0

Very professional and helpful. Very safe facility.

Everything is going well

by Wayne

September 11, 2019

5.0

Everything is going well I was treated Great by the woman who waited on me

Very great and quick service will...

by Michael Verange

December 17, 2018

5.0

Very great and quick service will definitely recommend to others

Totally professional

by Mark Paviluk

April 10, 2018

5.0

Totally professional. All questions answered.

John Antinora's profileJohn Antinora
October 21, 2025

I am currently renting two storage units at the Public Storage facility in West Creek, NJ. I had the pleasure of speaking with Amanda and John, who were both extremely helpful in clearly explaining the details and process of securing the units I needed. They also informed me that I could complete the rental agreement at any Public Storage location, which provided great flexibility. On my way home from work, I visited the Middletown, NJ location, where Brian assisted me in completing the process. He was exceptionally courteous, knowledgeable, and efficient. His professionalism and customer service reflect very well on the company. Public Storage is fortunate to have him on their team.

Dominic Minn's profileDominic Minn
April 6, 2025

I had the pleasure of working with Kristin at the Public Storage location in Middletown, New Jersey, and I cannot speak highly enough of her level of professionalism and customer service. From the moment I walked in, Kristin greeted me with a warm and welcoming smile, making me feel right at home. Her knowledge of the facility and services was impeccable. She took the time to thoroughly explain my options and helped me choose the right storage unit that suited my needs perfectly. Not only was she patient in answering all of my questions, but she also went above and beyond by offering helpful tips on how to best organize and store my items to maximize space. Kristin's attention to detail and genuine care for her customers is truly outstanding. She made the entire process seamless, from initial inquiry to the final paperwork. It was clear that she takes great pride in her work, and it’s rare to find someone so dedicated to providing such excellent service. Thanks to Kristin, my experience with Public Storage in Middletown was stress-free and enjoyable. If you ever need assistance, I highly recommend reaching out to her—you won’t be disappointed!

Noel C.'s profileNoel C.
March 22, 2025

I recently had a fantastic experience with Public Storage, thanks to Kristin!. Immediately following my attempts to make a reservation online I received a call from kristin to gather more information. At that time Kristin was helpful and provided all the information I needed upfront and was very sincere and knowledgeable. I highly recommend this place for their outstanding service. Thank you so much

Brian Schindler's profileBrian Schindler
June 5, 2025

I worked with Kristin from the Middletown, NJ storage facility, and she was fantastic! I had a transfer/scheduling issue stemming from being directed to the overall call center and Kristin worked with me on the phone for over a half hour to make sure everything was corrected and I wasn't improperly charged. She also ensured that I had a unit available to switch to when I needed it, as we were consolidating to a smaller storage space. She was very patient, professional, and courteous and provided outstanding customer service! Thank you, Kristin!!

William McDavitt's profileWilliam McDavitt
July 16, 2025

Met with kristin today, she explained to me how the public storage rental unit process works. I described what i believed what i needed based on what was left in my home, she gave me a couple of recommendations took the time to show me different units. Explained the benefits of climate controlled vs non climate control which helped me make the decision to get the unit . She was great if there was more then 5 stars she would of gotten more. You should be proud to have an associate like her in your company.

How to Rent a Storage Unit With Storage.com

There are two easy ways to secure a unit at this storage facility

1You can complete your rental process online today and go straight to your unit when you plan to move in.
2You can make a reservation today with no payment until you sign your lease at your move-in date.
How It Works
Search icon
Select your storage unit
Reserve icon
Reserve for free

Cancel or change your reservation at any time, risk-free

Move in icon
Move in